VIDEO: Mother of Pitbull Attack Victim Defends Dog
The mother of 5-year-old Grace Martens, who was bitten by a pitbull Tuesday morning, says the dog was "just playing."
The mother of the 5-year-old girl, who was bitten by a pitbull Tuesday morning, is defending the dog that reportedly attacked her daughter.
Vanessa Martens, the mother of Grace Martens, says the dog was "just playing" when he bit the 5-year-old.
"He's not a vicious dog," Vanessa Martens says. "...He was just playing and then he got scared ... It was a huge accident."
Martens discusses the events of Tuesday morning in the video above.
Police were called to an Island Avenue home Tuesday morning for a pitbull attack. The girl was dropped off to see her mother, who happened to be at the house visiting. The mother does not own the dog.
According to Martens, the girl was playing tug-of-war with the pitbull, a 1-year-old puppy, when he bit her arm.
A 26-year-old neighbor, Wyatt Joaquin, witnessed the attack and ran to assist the girl. Joaquin tells WPRI he jumped over the fence to help.
The girl sustained serious injuries to her arm and was transported by Portsmouth Rescue to Newport Hospital and later to Hasbro Children's Hospital. She has since been treated and released from the hospital.
Grace now wears a cast on her arm, which her mother says is protecting four stitches. However, she was back playing at the house Wednesday morning, smiling and laughing. She also played with a neighbor's dog just a day after the attack.
"I'm fine with dogs, but not vicious dogs," Grace says while holding her doll. "I want the dog back when my cast is off."
In accordance with state law, the dog is being quarantined for 14 days at the Potter League for Animals. The dog's owner could be asked to attend a vicious dog hearing in the future.
Martens says she wants to temporarily board the pitbull at K-9 Instincts in Portsmouth. There, the child's mother wants the puppy to undergo training before he is back playing in the yard.
aqisland
7:57 am on Thursday, June 7, 2012
thank GOD a good neighbor came to the rescue! Please realize this could have been much worse. At this point, there should be no 2nd chance for that dog in my opinion-your little girl is lucky to be alive! your little girl should be priority, NOT the dog! who cares if its a pitbull or a poodle, your girl was attacked! get rid of it!
outside look
8:08 am on Thursday, June 7, 2012
I'm sorry but did she just say that the pitbull plays tug of war with the little girl? I play tug of war with my dog and he's 17 pounds and has accidently nipped me while playing. That is so not a game for a girl to play with a pitbull that can reach up to and over 100 pounds. I'm glad the girl is ok but the mother might want to rethink how she is training the dog..
Other side of the fence
9:01 am on Thursday, June 7, 2012
My husband is a facial surgeon. They are lucky the neighbor intervened. It could have been so much worse. Cannot tell you how many times in the past 20 years he has had to stitch up a child's face because the dog "never hurt anyone before". These kids carry the scars on their face for a lifetime.
East side
9:51 am on Thursday, June 7, 2012
This child is going to need to mental therapy later in life. "Mom loved the dog more than she loved me". I have a scar on my arm to show it.
Luca
9:55 am on Thursday, June 7, 2012
The Nanny Dog
http://www.ywgrossman.com/photoblog/?p=676
Sweetie Pie
3:14 pm on Monday, June 11, 2012
The Nanny Dog, but this time for real
http://thetruthaboutpitbulls.blogspot.nl/2010/08/nanny-dog-myth-revealed.html
ipmom
9:56 am on Thursday, June 7, 2012
Couldnt agree more... if she actually was a good mom then she would never let the dog back in her house. Instead she is defending the dog.
401islander
10:08 am on Thursday, June 7, 2012
the little girl wants the dog to come home!!!!!!!!!!! you people have no idea what you are taking about! how about people ask how the little girl is doing, but nooo all you guys wanna do is bash the dog and the family for having the dog!
East side
10:24 am on Thursday, June 7, 2012
The girl would be doing a lot better had this ANIMAL not been in the house. To have a dog of this nature around a child is a situation of danger. It very well could happen again and many more people could be hurt. Not to mention the time, money, and safety of our fire/police should there be another situation.
TAMORI
10:44 am on Thursday, June 7, 2012
My kids want to eat candy and fatty, surgery snacks all day and stay up until after midnight watching TV on school nights. But since I don’t know what I’m talking about I guess I’ll let them do it.
Ripper
6:55 pm on Thursday, June 7, 2012
did you see her arm that day? no?....ok....If a dog ripped your arm apart while it was "playing" would you be quick to get it back? Now what if it was your little girl? hmm?
Sandy McGee
10:21 am on Thursday, June 7, 2012
I'd like to remind everyone to please refrain from making personal attacks against a user. This is a violation of our Terms of Use, which can be viewed more here - http://portsmouth.patch.com/terms.
TAMORI
11:12 am on Thursday, June 7, 2012
From the video:
“It’s only a puppy. Only a year old.”
“It’s too young to be a vicious dog.”
“I realized there was no way I was strong enough to get this dog off of her.”
But it’s just a puppy and for whatever reason it did attack. In a year it will be nearly full grown, weigh around 60 lbs, and there may not be anyone nearby to help. That is one cute little girl. I’m glad she’s OK and that the dog didn’t grab her face.
Sweetie Pie
10:41 pm on Tuesday, July 31, 2012
Good for you! Thank you! A dog is a puppy until it's at most sixteen weeks old. A yearling is not a puppy. A yearling is starting to show what it's going to be as an adult dog. All the same, it's not at full body-weight or (in the case of a pit-type) full adult aggression yet.
Very distasteful when people call a year-old dog a puppy. Weird even.
Portsmouth Outsider
11:20 am on Thursday, June 7, 2012
Oh Please...What are you folks missing jumping on the Bandwagon..I guess your calling the Mother & the little girl a liar? Anyone that has a puppy/young dog knows they nip and can be rough until "trained" properly.
Prob not a good idea having a young child around any dog when it is young but clearly as it says "an ACCIDENT".
Some of you anti-dog people are ridiculous similar happened to me however, I had a nasty non understanding dishonest neighbor and when drunk put his hand over my fence, in my property to pet the puppy who on instinct grabbed his arm to PLAY a big dog at that so a stronger grip...and did accidentally break the skin..A dog that is now a "Big Baby" who would let someone beat the crap out of him....
Would suit some better to be less judgmental, stop reading between the lines and accept what the VERY "Decent, honest, woman & her daughter are saying" and get off your high horses. Yes, she is a truthful, honest person I would like as a neighbor/friend...she & her little girl have to be commended for being honest about this. She knows, she was there...Duh!...Nobody here was.
This is clearly NOT a vicious Dog attack, an Accident ...I agree with one thing...best to keep young children away from young dogs........
and then there is the stupid people who think they can invade a Dog's territory, then complain about it. Some remarks here remind me of them.
Ripper
6:58 pm on Thursday, June 7, 2012
I would usually agree with you....but if you live on that street you know the truth and would be angry as well. Portsmouth is a small community and lies usually dont go to far without someone finding the truth.
Sweetie Pie
10:40 pm on Tuesday, July 31, 2012
Anit-pitbull is by definition NOT anti-dog. Pit bull behavior deviates too strongly from the behavior of the normal domestic dog, and they are killing so many more normal dogs than they are killing even children and adult humans -- we must conclude that pro-pitbull is by definition anti-dog.
Pit bulls aren't dogs. They are the product of a human genetic engineering project that took some 400 years to achieve. Frankenmauler is an apt name for this genetically modified non-dog. More accurate than calling the thing a dog.
These biological and statistical facts mean that you can't love pit bulls and also love dogs. It's one or the other.
So those of us here who are against pit bulls are the only real dog lovers participating. You pit-lovers are the only anti-dog people present.
caitlyn casey
3:23 pm on Thursday, June 7, 2012
Guess what I WAS there and it was a vicious attack the dog refused to let go and then aftet got it off of her arm it tried for only her AGAIN so maybe you ahould rethink what your writing cause clearly YOU WEREN'T THERE
Ripper
6:59 pm on Thursday, June 7, 2012
I saw it....the dog wasnt "playing"....
portscitizen
3:26 pm on Thursday, June 7, 2012
Why don't you people leave this poor family alone. This was an accident end of story. If this was any other breed of dog it would be a non-issue. Keep throwing the stones while you live in your glass houses! This is getting ridiculous.
Ripper
7:00 pm on Thursday, June 7, 2012
if this was on your street would you be saying that as well?...Its easy not to be judgemental when the grass is greener on the other side?
portscitizen
8:53 am on Friday, June 8, 2012
Grass isn't greener on my side of the street. I have two small yappy dogs in my neighborhood that get loose and go after people all the time. Only reason nobody hears about these goes biting, etc. is because they aren't pitbulls. So don't play the neighborhood card it could happen anywhere.
Sweetie Pie
10:40 pm on Tuesday, July 31, 2012
Right. You get a pit bull, then when it attacks someone it's just a freak accident. Never happened before in all of history, couldn't possibly have been foreseen!
How dare you say it would be a non-issue if it were some other breed of dog? When other dogs maim or kill, it certainly makes the news. The reason you don't see this so often is because they don't do it so often -- unlike pit bulls. Hahaha, ooooo, bad rap! Ya know, if the pits would stop mauling, maiming, dismembering and killing, their bad rap would be over. Hey, why don't you whisper that in their ears, maybe they'll listen. I mean, if they're tired of the ACCURATE and JUSTIFIED bad press their behavior is getting them.
From your second comment here I conclude that you are a pit owner who is worried your pit/s might attack one of these small dogs you pass on a walk (and you have to pay the vet bills), or otherwise that you don't have any kind of pet at all and are just here being coy.
caitlyn casey
6:32 pm on Thursday, June 7, 2012
Oh yeah and the skin wasn't just broken it was torn along with a fractured wrist of it was an accident wouldn't this dog have let go when it realised it had her arm?and ir has NOTHING to do with the fact it was a pitbull if any oyher dog did that id be saying the same damn thing therefore, I don't want it living across from me every single day when the gf wiuld leave the house and open that gate the dog was running up and down the street and she's yelling it chasing it trying to get it in the yard and it wouldn't listen...now after biting and rufusing to let go is not a dog I was running free on my street...some of us do care about the well being of ourselves and children and would rather not roll the dice again he's bitten once he's gone as far as I'm concerned
steve roderiques
7:35 pm on Thursday, June 7, 2012
My dog has never bitten anyone before. Find a police report that accused my dog of that. You won't because that girl got beat up in my house not attacked by a puppy
Sweetie Pie
10:40 pm on Tuesday, July 31, 2012
Caitlyn, you are right -- any dog that does this to a person (or another animal fo that matter) should be humanely put down. This doesn't need to be breed-specific. It's justice no matter the type of dog, besides being prevention for a repeat.
The big BUT is that when lawmakers propose anything like this, it's the pit fans that come out to protest. They know that it will most of all be their pitty-patty wiggle-butts being put down.
I hope you'll be willing after this incident to campaign for a law that says (not breed-specific) that any dog that seriously injures a human or another animal must be gently put to death. Great idea you presented here.
steve roderiques
7:33 pm on Thursday, June 7, 2012
My dog has never bitten anyone before. Find a police report that accused my dog of that. You won't because that girl got beat up in my house not attacked by a puppy
Islander
8:53 am on Friday, June 8, 2012
Beat up?? Well now I really think you are a mature pitbull owner. You guys should just stop commenting cuz your making yourselves look even worse.
wyatt erp
8:53 am on Friday, June 8, 2012
thats a playful puppy hate to c what he can do when he's a grown pit. that dog should not be around kids and if her own mother cant c that then god watch over her kid cause shes gonna need it. this is the one who pryed the dogs jaws off her kid im disgusted by that interveiw
Islander
9:52 am on Friday, June 8, 2012
Maybe DHS should be called. I normally would think that is a terrible idea but in this case the mother seems more worried about the 3 month relationship with the boyfriend and his dog than her on daughter. If that dog goes back to that home they are endangering not only that little girl but every kid on that street! And don't attack me cuz I love pits and I had one with kids but if that dog ever bit my kids or anyone for that matter he would be put to sleep! It's like people care more about animals than the safety of a human life. I just don't understand people anymore.
Stephanie
10:14 am on Friday, June 8, 2012
Someone who wants to return to a home where their daughter has been a viciously attacked by a dog (regardless of breed...I am a large breed dog owner myself) is baffling to me. As a parent you are supposed to protect your young, not continuously expose them to harm.I think this is a form of neglect. Maybe mom should reconsider her relationship for the safety of her daughter. This is the most disturbing story I have heard. Thank god someone was willing to risk their own life to help out, and thank god the girl is okay!!!
ralph
10:14 am on Friday, June 8, 2012
Tug of war with a dog may seem like a game to people, but to a dog it is a way of showing or building dominance. It is a pack mentality of a dog to try and move up the pack order. Now of course not everybody knows this fact, but I can understand the dog getting confused, after accidentally biting the little girl. When the neighbor tried to remove the dog, it would be the dogs natural instinct to react in an aggressive or defensive manner. I am still of the opinion that pitbulls although non-aggressive in say a loving household, still have instinctual tendacies to become aggressive with out warning. The fact of the matter is these dogs were bred to be agressive. Cruel treatment of these animals just enhances their agressive behavior. Not every dog is a tinking time bomb of course. However, (IMO) this breed is more apt to become aggressive percentage wise, than most other dog breeds.
Green Firefly
10:14 am on Friday, June 8, 2012
Thankfully a neighbor was there, and did come to her aide. These same neighbors now have the right to voice their concern. The breed of dog is a non-issue, the issue remains that the dog did bite a child and refuse to let go. As a dog owner/lover myself - I would be devestated if my dog bit any child and refused to let go. Understandably puppies play and my inadvertently nip the person they are playing with, this was not the case here based on the childs injuries and eyewitness accounts. A dog of any breed that did cause that type damage to a child should not be allowed back in any home. It is unfortunate and I am sure very painful for the family to lose their pet, not as painful as a permanent injury to their child or someone elses.
Islander
11:30 am on Friday, June 8, 2012
*dcyf
pr
12:15 pm on Friday, June 8, 2012
You people don't get that my story is distorted the dog is not coming back here because accident or not I font want my child to be a victim again my story was suppose to put an end to the rumors and lies saying the dog was always in the yard looking for a fight and that the dog was being trained for dog fighting and that I had my kid in an environment with a vicious dog I was trying to prove the point that my child was never in any harm until that day...... It is painful loosing a pet a do feel bad for my boyfriend but I am thankful my child is okay and you can believe if for some reason the dog is allowed to come back here me and my child won't
Sweetie Pie
10:40 pm on Tuesday, July 31, 2012
pr, as you (pit nutter) pretend to be this girl's mother, you forgot to look at the mother's name. You should be posting this BS as vm, ya know...
portsmouthperson
2:28 pm on Friday, June 8, 2012
EVERYONE! Please, I beg you to just leave this family alone. No matter who was wrong, or what happened. The little girl is still just that, a little girl. Vanessa is still a mother and no one deserves this much crap from everyone. I'm not on eaither side... I dont know the family or the dog... But I do think that this is a small town, a horrible thing has happened, and bashing the woman wont help. Please lets focus our attention on other things and let this just go away.
Cynthia Leary-Johnson
4:34 pm on Friday, June 8, 2012
My goodness is this the Portsmouth that I know and love? I think not. Portsmouthperson I am with you 100%. Let it go, it's alright.
Portsmouth Outsider
10:12 am on Monday, June 11, 2012
In the picture is the "white band-aid" the damage to the child's arm?...
Where's the Cast?..I do not see signs of a "vicious attack"....other thn a bandaid....
I do not get it...the mother is here replying to multiple topics on this....posting in 2 different names...The Mother should NOT have to do that.?
Arcticle says she DOES NOT own the dog and she says: her and her daughter won't be back if the dog gets back....then she says on another topic...she is the owner.... It does not say anywhere it was "a vicious attack" it has been named that by people here....
Wonder if the dog is getting a bad rap here...None of this story seems to be straight!.
BTW.....
Did you know in rescue the #1 explanation given to rescue's for "giving up" a dog is it either did bite someone, attempted to, or is assumed agressive enough it might... .and a lot of the time it is just used as the excuse/reason to rid themselves of the animal for whatever reason ....other than the real one...while feeling they will not look bad for doing so.... The dog pays the price, so as the owner can feel good for getting rid of it.
What they do not know is that is a instant death sentence to a dog into rescue...as they are deemed non adoptable and PTS.
TAMORI
6:53 pm on Monday, June 11, 2012
Outsider - did you play the video? The little girl's left arm is in a cast.
caitlyncasey
10:12 am on Monday, June 11, 2012
" it was and accident, and unfortunately the dog is being blammed and he shouldn't be" don't think any words were twisted thar came out of your mouth...who should be blammed then?accident-he refused to let go- far from an accident-
Islander
3:55 pm on Tuesday, June 12, 2012
A pitbulls jaw only locks when they are being aggressive....so I really doubt that it was just playing. You should never let a little child play tug of war with a dog cuz that is away for dogs to decide who is higher in the pack. She keeps making the excuse that the dog is just a puppy but he is a year old.....and a dog that is a year old is capable of killing or attacking a human. And by other comments it looks like the mother has only been dating the guy for 2-3 months so the dog hasn't known this child long. Maybe the dog is jealous of the child....it happens. And if the dog goes back to this home...the women said she wont be going there...so who will let the dog out when I'm assuming the guys at work? And a pitbull cooped up in a house all day is a bad idea....thats how you get aggressive pitbulls....a lack of exercise and contact with people and other dogs can make him aggressive tords new people and new situations. There should have to be a class people have to take and pass to own a dog that is high on the aggressive list. It's not just pitbulls that attack so people should be aware to never trust a dog alone with a small child.
Deb Hunter Tomaskovic
2:55 pm on Monday, July 30, 2012
Diapelling a myth.....
Pitties do NOT have locking jaws:
http://www.dogwatch.net/myths/lock_jaw.html
Peggy
8:13 pm on Monday, July 30, 2012
Deb Hunter: The article is probably correct. As the article suggests, the pit bull can not LOCK it's jaws..mechanically. HOWEVER: The pit bulls actions are controlled by the pit bulls BRAIN. The brain says "Hold On" and the jaw holds on. Just the way it is.
Same with people; The BRAIN is what drives us.
Unbelievable
4:29 pm on Friday, June 15, 2012
http://usnews.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/06/15/12238400-8-month-old-boy-dies-after-dog-attack-near-san-diego?lite
Thankfully this is not portsmouth in the news. Appalling to me how many ingnorant pitbull owners there are out there.
RoastPuppy
11:10 am on Monday, July 30, 2012
Even if this 4-legged shark was "only playing" and we all know this isn't true, the dog BROKE THE CHILD'S ARM!!!! If you had a stroller in which a child could get its arm caught and break it, you'd be wanting to sue the manufacturer for selling an unsafe product. This monster attacked the child and she is lucky that all she received was a broken arm. The next time, she could have her arm or leg torn off, or be scalped as so many children have been when attacked by pit bulls. Vanessa Martens isn't fit to be a mother and child protective services should remove Grace from her custody and place her with someone who is more concerned about the child than they are some worthless killer fleabag!
Sweetie Pie
10:25 am on Tuesday, July 31, 2012
RoastPuppy, you're right. I find it very sad that this little girl apparently knows the only way to keep her mother's 'love' (if you can call it that) is to say she wants the non-dog that did this to her back. This mother is setting her daughter up to accept any and all abuse later in life (hmmmm, and now too) -- from battering to rape to scalping by pit bull -- and always feel she must excuse and defend her poor, poor abuser. It's such a psychologically unhealthy situation that I agree with you, the girl needs to be removed from it. She needs to be surrounded by people who tell her it's not okay for anyone or anything to abuse or hurt her. That her abusers shouldn't be excused but rather punished, and that she'll be protected from them ever coming near her again.
We are, with this pit-bull insanity, collectively letting our children down in an inexcusable way. I love normal dogs, but I love children too. It's disgusting that we are, collectively, exposing children to the nightmare of having to live next door to or in the same house with any dog that hurt them.
I guess it's not just this mother who thinks the pit-bull type dog is more important that any child. I guess it's also our politicians and judges. I'm totally baffled as to how we got to this sick place we seem to be at.
Thanks for your post.
kyle
2:55 pm on Monday, July 30, 2012
@RoastPuppy - you are a troll
Sweetie Pie
10:25 am on Tuesday, July 31, 2012
I've flagged your comment as inappropriate. A pit fan dashing in to call anyone who disagrees with them a troll is a common tactic, but all the same it's unacceptable.
Steveinri
6:14 pm on Monday, July 30, 2012
This is the kind of response I had expected out of the owner of the dog.
Clearly the dog learned from it's master.
Sweetie Pie
10:25 am on Tuesday, July 31, 2012
Yes, Steveinri, the dog knew it was more important to this hybristophiliac woman than the child was. The dog is still more important than the child. If the thing is allowed to go home, the next incident will be deadly for this little girl. I feel sorry for any child stuck in a home like this one.
kyle
10:54 am on Monday, August 6, 2012
@Sweetie Pie why dont you flag Roast Puppy? Calling any specific dog breed "monsters" is inappropriate and unacceptable. And doing that with a name like "Roast Puppy" is trolling.
Jane Clarke
10:19 am on Monday, October 15, 2012
kyle, please quote the US law that states "calling any specific dog breed 'monsters' is inappropriate and unacceptable." Dogs are animals, animals have no protections under the US constitution. Pit bulls are: 4-legged sharks, land-sharks, killing machines, and there are a lot of other names for them that I cannot use because profanity isn't allowed here. And YOU, kyle, are no better than the MONSTERS you defend!
Rouben
11:35 am on Thursday, February 14, 2013
Bunch of ignorance. Pit Bull jaws do not "Lock", and their temperament rates much better than many other breeds. The public against the pit bull is modern day animal racism. People can't be openly racist against blacks and Latinos anymore, time to be racist against a wonderful and loyal breed that percentage wise is low on the attack pole, but has been given a bad rep and bad name by the brainwashing media. If the dog wanted to hurt the girl she would have a lot more than 4 stitches. Probably missed the toy and grabbed the arm. The kid should not have been playing tug of with a young and not fully trained dog. Why aren't we talking about Rotweilers, German Sheppards, Rhodesian Ridgebacks and other guard breeds? This is ridiculous and is being used as basis to pass expensive and unreasonable statewide laws.
Ripper
4:51 pm on Thursday, February 14, 2013
Dog was put down...end of story