patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Should Portsmouth Attempt to Control the Coyote Population? [Poll]

Should the town of Portsmouth try to control the coyote population?

 

As the days grow shorter and winter eventually sets in, the food supply for coyotes will grow more scarce and the risk to pets and livestock might increase.

According to the Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management (DEM), Coyotes have been part of Rhode Island’s fauna for more than 30 years and are an important component of the ecosystem.

The DEM claims that campaigns to reduce the population are expensive and are generally unsuccessful. Despite that, several Middletown residents have called for coyote population control.

"It's hunting season, let's get some professionals down here to take care of this once and for all," said reader Paul Bertel. A reader who goes by the alias ALL animal lover added that residents should not have to bear the complete financial burden of protecting their pets, such as expensive fences.

“Aquidneck Islanders need to band together and do something about this...our silence is not helping our cause,” said Sandra.

Not all readers agreed.

“Nature has a way to keep everything in balance and when man interferes he ends up paying the price in the end,” said Robert E.

What do you think? Should Portsmouth attempt to control the coyote population? Take our poll below.

  • Should Portsmouth attempt to control the coyote population?

    (Voting has been closed for this question)
    • Yes
        25 (52%)
    • No
        23 (47%)
    Total votes: 48
  • Your vote will only count once. This is not a scientific poll. View Results Vote!
Related Topics: Coyotes

TheOneCalledZed

7:52 am on Tuesday, October 2, 2012

The coyote population does not survive on puppies and kittens - the greatest part of their diet is small rodents (pests.) Beyond that, they are opportunistic and uncovered food trash is the single resource that is most likely to lead to "abnormal" population surges. I have no problem with "control" measures, but for a lot of people the target is to eradicate the species from the island and I would not support that.

Reply

TAMORI

8:30 am on Tuesday, October 2, 2012

RIDEM - “Coyotes have been part of Rhode Island’s fauna for more than 30 years and are an important component of the ecosystem.”

How does an animal become such an "important" component of a small ecosystem, such as Aquidneck Island, in less than half a century? I mean if they weren’t here 50 years ago does that mean the island’s ecosystem was all out of whack somehow? I don’t think they need to be completely eradicated from the island. Controlled probably but not eradicated. Is someone at RIDEM trying to mislead us?

Reply

Tuna man

10:56 am on Tuesday, October 2, 2012

The Coyote was wiped out almost 200 years ago in most of the US and Canada by our forefathers for a number of reasons. They were a danger and a pest to the people who had to live with them. A small child was an inviting food source easily taken. Then the live stock and finally family pets were also prime food for them. They are a predator who will always take an easy meal if they find it. More and more people in Rhode Island will be finding them staring at them one day if they have a child or a small pet with them. Guess what? They are on the menu so the best thing is to once more get rid of them before someone get hurt by them now and not after the fact. There are a lot more of them around then some people want to admit to and the danger is just increasing with each little they raise. The time to act is now before it's too late.

Reply

Jay Miller

11:07 am on Tuesday, October 2, 2012

The gentleman who posted about the "history" of coyotes speaks with no knowledge of the facts. There is NO reported account of a coyote attacking a person. Coyotes do NOT attack nor eat people. His language is intended to incite fear, the worst ingredient for making intelligent choices.

We human beings chose to live where other wildlife must live. It's not that difficult for us to coexist with other species. After all, they want the same things that we want: they want food, shelter, safety and a place to raise their young. We can easily accommodate their desires and not give up much of our own. Do NOT put cat or dog food outside; feed your animals indoors. Do NOT let your pets wander, stray, without your being present. That's good for them, and for you. Do not leave your garbage without secure lids. That's being a good neighbor, too.

If the people of Aquidneck Island allow their government representatives to "eradicate" coyotes, they will allow two things to happen. The first is they will fail to achieve the intended results. Coyotes will never be eradicated. Attempts to do so have failed. Coyotes, unbelievably, readjust their breeding habits to account for environmental conditions. There will likely always be coyotes. And, secondly, the people of this island will allow an inhumane, unintelligent and anti-nature event to take place.

The answer is to make some adjustments, learn to live with coyotes and Nature, and thank goodness you are privileged to do so.

Reply
Comment_arrow

chickadee

7:33 am on Saturday, January 26, 2013

Excellent post Jay Miller. The fact that statistically a person/child and or their dog is more likely to be attacked by a domestic dog is constantly ignored is beyond me. We don't seem to realize either the balance of all things in nature - if coyotes are eating rodents, and even deer, people should be cheering the fact that can help reduce tick populations. Maybe we can start a campaign for those that are so anthropocentric that the only way they can understand anything about nature is how it might be of value to them, instead of being afraid.

Portsmouth Outsider

12:41 pm on Tuesday, October 2, 2012

I agree with Jay Miller...very well said.

DEM would best use whatever $ they have for making sure the many Rules & Regulations that are already in place, are upheld regarding "hunting season"...they have a very long list of do's and dont's, but fail miserably on seeing they are upheld, claiming they do not have enough staff.

If they have a hard time upholding and policing the many rules they have set out already, why add more responsibility by adding yet more Policy's while also needing more employee's for the job.

It's one thing making the Rules....another, enforcing them.

If it is so important to those that want eradication of Coyotes, they should get together as a group & pay for all that may be required themselves.

Reply

Starting to Wonder

12:46 pm on Tuesday, October 2, 2012

Zed and Jay, both right on. Fear and ignorance is what is driving people right now, rather than knowledge and intelligent choices, and trying to eradicate a species to suit us is never a good idea. Don't unintentionally feed coyotes so they retain their natural fear of humans. Don't leave your pets alone outside - there are plenty of other dangers out there besides coyotes anyway. Let's learn to coexist properly. Treat the coyote like it's a wild animal, like a skunk or a racoon - nothing you want to cuddle with, but nothing that needs to be slaughtered either. It has it's place.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Disgusted

11:29 am on Thursday, October 4, 2012

I recently moved so that my dog could have a nice big yard to play in. I had a coyote in that back yard two weeks ago. Had my dog been in the yard, he would have been taken and dragged back to the den and eaten by a pack of coyotes. Since then, I will not let him in the yard. Even if it I am with him or leash him, do you really think I could stop the attack. Why can't my dog go out and sit in his backyard without the threat of being killed?
Coyotes are wild animals who are disturbing our way of life and have become a severe threat to society and need to be eradicated.

Robert E

1:01 pm on Tuesday, October 2, 2012

The reason we have a coyote problem right now is because we killed off all the wolves. If we kill off all the coyotes what other predator will take there place.

Reply

RINHS

1:20 pm on Tuesday, October 2, 2012

Coyotes are not the problem. Coyotes are supposed to be social pack animals, hunters, and shy. If they were all these, you would probably never even know they were there. They'd just get busy with beneficial behaviors, like keeping down the population of deer. When a coyote is getting easy pickings from humans...uncovered trash, road-kill deer, or pet food, he or she doesn't need to obey the rules of a pack, begins to associate humans with food, and loses its shyness. The perfect storm is If your neighbor is feeding the local coyotes and then goes on vacation. Pretty soon you've got bold, hungry, scavengers hanging around your yard. Allowing coyotes to mooch food from you is not fair to your fellow community members. It is threat to public health and safety. It's also unsafe for local pets and for the coyotes themselves. Jay's exactly right...without saying it's never okay to hunt coyotes, it is usually useless to do so. Shooting, trapping, and poisoning are not risk-free to the neighborhood either, and that risk is hard to bear when we know that it will not resolve the problem.

Reply

TheOneCalledZed

1:25 pm on Tuesday, October 2, 2012

When the expanding (non-native) human population drove coyotes out of this area, the ecosystem responded by allowing "rebounds" and "surges" in prey populations: foxes, skunks, racoons, possums, and, most of all, rats and mice. For a long time the only controlling predator we had were raptors and their habitat, too, was under pressure from us. Our wild animal populations are controlled by complex mechanisms, and simplistic solutions almost always have unintended consequences.

Reply

Tuna man

2:48 pm on Tuesday, October 2, 2012

Too many of you don't know a darn thing about these coyotes. They are dangerous. AND Jay Miller your should really know what your talking about before making false statements. Just a year or two ago a seven year old boy was attacked and was being pulled into the woods by a coyote right here in Rhode Island when it was driven off. This has happened all around the country and it is increasing. The first thing to do is to get the idots who are feeding them to stop. They are not dogs.They are not cute. They are not pets, they are wild animals and the can hurt people.

Reply
Comment_arrow

TAMORI

3:47 pm on Tuesday, October 2, 2012

Tuna – They are a dogs. Their scientific name is Canis Latrans (barking dog). And they are beautiful animals. But you are correct…they’re not pets, they are wild animals. But that doesn’t mean they need to be killed off.

Comment_arrow

clarence

9:52 pm on Tuesday, October 2, 2012

In Sea Berry farm inPortsmouth one womem feeds them on her farm

Comment_arrow

Rachel Carter

5:33 pm on Wednesday, October 3, 2012

Where did you find this information? I only found a blog that mentioned it when I googled it, which isn't exactly a reputable or reliable source. Plus that sounds like a rabid animal attack. The lyssavirus causes what's called furious rabies in most carnivores, this will includes clinical signs like unprovoked aggression and mental confusion. Rabies would explain this supposed uncharacteristically bold and aggressive move.

Jon Sisson

4:07 pm on Tuesday, October 2, 2012

Don't feed any wild animal for that matter. These species have lived just fine without handouts. Especially seagulls! :P Just remember, what goes in, must come out!

Reply

Gene Love

5:01 pm on Tuesday, October 2, 2012

WOW ! - Lots of Misinformation and opinions that are based on a lack of factual knowledge. If you are truly interested in factual information about the Coyote and more importantly interested in reliable detailed information about the Coyote population and activity on Aquidneck Island - Go to the "Narragansett Bay Coyote Study" (NBCS) web-site http://theconservationagency.org/coyote.htm

Reply

Ellie ferri

8:11 am on Wednesday, October 3, 2012

Coyotes do attack humans when they want your dog for dinner and you try to save it or interfere. It happened twice in my neighborhood in Florida. Little dogs should never be left unattended. We also have hawks and owls who can and will take them for dinner. I do not think hunting them would help much but I DO think that when one starts stalking a human who is walking his dog it needs to be caught and killed. I also think there should be big fines for the people who feed them and therefore put other people in danger from coyotes who are not afraid of humans. Two coyotes tried to snatch my 6 pound dog in my yard in sea meadows a few years ago. I yelled and they ran away. I have seen coyotes many times going down the street in sea meadows as well as around the St Barnabus church area in Portsmouth.

Reply

TheOneCalledZed

2:24 pm on Wednesday, October 3, 2012

Fact is, as long as humans and their stuff is involved, it is almost impossible for the surrounding ecosystem to achieve a stable (if dynamic) balance. We snuffed out the coyotes from around here, along with a lot of other species, but now some of them are finding ways to exploit the niches that we create. I mention this because the enterprising coyotes who have re-colonized our island (and elsewhere) have done so successfully because they have no predator to limit their population so the only limit is habitat and food resources. The coyote (there is a reason "Wiley" is a coyote) are very clever at adapting their behavior to the new situation and so habitat does not appear to be a near limit, and with garbage, pet food, and misguided fan feeding, I suspect that the food supply will not be that limit. Turns out, then, that we, the humans, might have to become the controlling predator, as is done in the West. These programs, run by wildlife professionals, are aimed at keeping things reasonable, not eradication of a species. Given that the votes in the PP poll are just about evenly split, a compromise program of measurement and culling might be the best practice. (I think very highly of coyotes and want them in my world, but I do recognize that having wild carnivores in the neighborhood is going to cause some problems.)

Reply

getreal

3:21 pm on Wednesday, October 3, 2012

Pass a law like Middletown did, do not feed and enforce it with fines.

Reply

Ellie ferri

9:12 pm on Thursday, October 4, 2012

A coyote attacked the dog next door to me last night oct 4. I live on sherwood terrace near st Barnabus church. That also means the same coyote is wandering in the windstone area and fairview lane and roger Williams court. People please keep your small children and pets very close during the day and in the house after dark and before sunrise. I have repeatedly seen this coyote during middle of the day so just because it is daylight it does not mean you pets are safe. This coyote is not afraid to be near humans. It goes across my yard on a regular basis.

Reply

Harry B.

2:06 pm on Tuesday, January 29, 2013

Having studied wild life biology, it is important to realize that Aquidneck Island creates a unique set of challenges for the coyote discussion. First, Eliminating them from an island is more likely than from the mainland, even with bridges. This conversation would not be happening in Sauderstown... Given that there is no room for expansion of habitat for the coyotes on this island, population pressures mean the coyotes will be pressed into neighborhoods in search of food and will take greater risks to procure food than in Saunderstown. This could lead to an increase an pet consumption. Best bet, utilize birth control and let them die off naturally. Yes, they'll come over the bridge or maybe even swim occasionally, but their numbers can always be kept in check.

Reply

pinta1

7:18 am on Saturday, February 2, 2013

I had a friend who was an experience hunter from Alaska. He was in Foster R.I. alone in the woods deer hunting. He was surrounded by a pack of six coyotes. Coyotes have been known to hunt in packs. If they are hungry enough they will take down a deer. He said he was glad he had his gun.
What I don't understand is if Ms.Mitchell from the coyote study is able to tag and collar them why isn't she neutering the males to help contain the population? I think the coyote study has run it's course. We should be using the money to trap and spray to control the population like Paws Watch does with the feral cats.

Reply

Leave a comment